Chapter 20. Discovery of Social Media Evidence

Information in this chapter:

• Legal issues in social media discovery
• Finding custodian of records contact information
• Facebook example
• Google information
• Online e-mail accounts
Social media evidence is a factor in more and more cases, both civil and criminal. Getting this type of evidence poses a challenge both from the standpoint of properly asking for the evidence but also in the ability to get the evidence due to both technical and legal barriers. In this chapter we will look at some of the methods for crafting subpoenas to obtain social media evidence from service providers.
Keywords
Facebook, Google, Discovery Language, Online E-mail, Custodian of Records

Introduction

There are more ways for people to connect with one another than ever before. The widespread use of social media outlets such as Facebook, Twitter, MySpace, and LinkedIn ultimately means that evidence is being created, and is often available right in the open.
However, many cases will require that you obtain more information than is available in the open on public profiles, such as the Internet address of the computer that created or updated a web post, or a Facebook profile blog post. To get this information you will need to subpoena the custodian of the social media service.
In order to obtain information from social media services via a subpoena, you will need to gather and send to them the information they need to identify the information you are requesting. This chapter covers the types of information you will need to include in subpoenas to social media and free e-mail sites. Examples are included for Facebook, Google’s Blogger service, and for free e-mail account services.
Social media evidence is covered in depth in Chapter 35. Online e-mail evidence is covered in Chapter 34.

20.1. Legal issues in social media discovery

One of the primary barriers to getting information from social media sites is the Stored Communications Act, 1 which prevents disclosure of information or e-mail stored by an Internet service provider. While the social media site is not technically an Internet service provider, they still fall under the same protection from disclosure in noncriminal actions.
The complete text of the Stored Communication Act can be accessed on the web at the U.S. Department of Justice, Computer Crime and Intellectual Property Section website at http://www.justice.gov/criminal/cybercrime/ssmanual/03ssma.html.

20.2. Finding custodian of records contact information

One of the best sources for finding the custodian of records contact information for social media sites, Internet service providers, and phone companies is the website Search2 at www.search.org. They maintain a listing of hundreds of addresses and phone numbers for custodians of records.

20.3. Facebook example

In order for Facebook to comply with a subpoena request, they must have the information they need to identify the profile. Profile identification can be in either of two forms, either a numeric ID or an alpha ID chosen by the Facebook user.
The old ID system used automatically generated numbers for the profile ID, such as https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1234567890. The group of numbers at the end of the web address or Uniform Resource Locator (URL) is the numerical profile ID. Bear in mind that the older numeric ID is an option for change by the user to the new ID. Not all users have made the change, so the numeric Facebook IDs are still very common.
The newer form looks like this: https://www.facebook.com/username. The part after the forward slash [/] at the end of the web address is the actual profile ID.
To locate these IDs, you only need to be able to find the user’s profile on Facebook, or they can be gathered from the Internet cache on the user’s hard drive during a forensic examination. Even if the person is not sharing their profile with the public, you can still see their profile ID in the web address in the browser if you can locate the profile on Facebook.
You will need to include the period of activity you are interested in having Facebook retrieve, as this will assist in getting back information more quickly. Also, any other identifying information you can supply can assist with locating and retrieving the online records, including birth date, e-mail addresses that may be associated with the account, and the person’s name.

20.3.1. Sample language to include for Facebook

Included here is the technical language you would use in a subpoena to Facebook including the identifying information for the user’s profile.
1. For the Facebook user account identified by the Facebook ID https://www.facebook.com/user.name, birth date of October 12, 1963, with the following e-mail addresses that may be connected to the Facebook user account, [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]
2. For the period of January 1, 2009 through May 1, 2010.
a. All activity for the user account including wall posts, chat logs, profile and album pictures, friend lists, and profile pages.
b. Original creation date of the user account and profile.
c. A log of all IP addresses used to access the account with date and time for each access and including the MAC address of the connecting computer for each connection.

20.4. Google information

Google is a massive presence on the Internet with a large number of services available to Internet users. In this example, we cover the Google Blogger service.
Some of the services they provide include: Search, Gmail, Talk, YouTube, Blogger, AdWords, AdSense, Checkout, Orkut, Picasa, Sites, Groups, Docs, Maps, Earth, Video, Android, and other Google Services. Google continues to expand their services by either introducing new services or purchasing existing services and rebranding them.
Here is the information you would want to use to subpoena Google for information about an online blog.

20.4.1. Google blogger example

In order for Google to comply with a request for information regarding a particular post from a user blog on the Blogger service, they need for you to supply specific information to identify the data you want them to retrieve. Getting all the information you need to get a proper response from Google on a blog post or blog site is somewhat technical. You may want to hire someone to assist you with gathering the information for your subpoena request.
• They will need the web address of the blog.
• They will need the internal ID of the blog.
• This is found in the source content of the page from the blog.
• They will need for you to supply the date and time of the blog post and the individual post ID.
• This information can also be found inside the page source by using the View Page Source feature in your Internet browser.
• They will also need the ID of the blog owner.
• The blog owner ID can be found by clicking on the blogger’s profile link, if it is shown on the blog.
• If you are interested in a single blog post, or several individual blog posts, the post ID for each one of them will be located and included in the subpoena.
• Also, for individual blog posts, they will want a copy of the content of the post as well.

20.4.2. Sample language for Google Blogger accounts and posts

Included here is a sample of the technical language you would use in your subpoena request to Google.
1. This is a request for historical records, including the originating Internet Protocol (IP) address for the creation of the blog, http://nameoftheblog.blogspot.com, identified by Google Blog ID: 1111111111111111111.
2. This request is for the timeframe beginning 1 June 2010 or beginning upon the creation date of the blog and continuing through 30 June 2010.
a. We specifically request the dates, times, and originating IP addresses for any actions by the author of the blog, http://nameoftheblog.blogspot.com, identified by Google Blog ID: 1111111111111111111, further identified by Blogger Profile ID, http://www.blogger.com/profile/000000000000000, including the blog creation, any posting activity, any post editing activity, and/or any activity requiring that the blogger “log in” as the owner of the blog for any purpose.
b. We specifically request the date, time, and originating IP address for the blog post identified as post ID=3333333333333333', including the original posting and the IP address of the connections for any subsequent edits of this post.
c. We request any user-provided identification, such as the blog owner’s e-mail address used when creating the blog http://nameoftheblog.blogspot.com, identified as Google blog ID=1111111111111111111 and Blogger Profile ID: 2222222222222222.
d. Attached to this subpoena is a copy of the blog text as captured from the Google Blogger website for this blog.

20.5. Online e-mail accounts

The language included in the following example can be used generically for any of the online e-mail account services such as Hotmail, Yahoo Mail, Microsoft Live Mail, America Online, and Gmail by replacing the name of the service with the appropriate name for the information you are seeking. Bear in mind that you may need to tweak this as many of these services may not provide e-mail content, especially for free accounts.
1. Any and all subscriber records regarding (AOL, Hotmail, Yahoo mail, Ymail, Microsoft Live mail, Google Gmail) and/or (AIM, Google Instant, Yahoo Chat) records regarding the identification of (e-mail address or chat handle) to include real name, screen names, status of account, detailed billing logs, date account opened and closed, method of payment, and detailed billing records.
2. If a time period is required for compliance with this subpoena, then the time period shall be for the period beginning on January 1, 2009 and ending on January 1, 2011.
a. Any and all connection logs to include the IP address, MAC address, and date and time of each connection.
b. To the extent that it is available and allowable under applicable law, any e-mail content that is available including e-mail messages, mailboxes, and contact lists.
c. A copy of your retention policies for the various types of content requested here.

Summary

In this chapter we looked at some examples for requesting information from various online services including e-mail, chats, blog posts, and Facebook. Included is the information needed to properly create a subpoena for the services used in the examples shown for Facebook profiles, Google Blogger accounts, and free e-mail accounts. In some cases, the information you need to use to craft the subpoena is fairly simple such as what you need for a free e-mail account. In other cases where you need to gather specific information like that shown in the Google Blogger example, you may want to get assistance from an expert or other person who can properly ferret out the details required for the subpoena.
References
[1]
[2]
..................Content has been hidden....................

You can't read the all page of ebook, please click here login for view all page.
Reset