Chapter 4
In This Chapter
Developing key mindful attitudes
Understanding ‘heartfulness’
Dealing with unhelpful attitudes
The greatest discovery of our generation is that human beings can alter their lives by altering their attitudes of mind. As you think, so shall you be.
William James
The three important aspects to mindfulness are intention, attitude and attention (explained fully in Chapter 3). This chapter focuses on attitude.
When it comes to attitude, you have a choice. If you’re aware of your outlook, you can begin to choose to change it for the better. Attitude isn’t about what happens in your life, how successful you are or even how you feel. You can be feeling the emotion of frustration but think, ‘Hey, at least I’m aware of it’ or ‘This is just a feeling’ or ‘This is a chance for me to understand the feeling of frustration’. Changing your attitude is difficult but is possible. By choosing mindful attitudes towards your moment-to-moment inner and outer experiences, you begin to release self-limiting beliefs and live life with greater fluidity.
Think about singing. What’s your attitude towards singing? Maybe you love it and can’t wait to jump up on the stage. If you don’t care what other people think, or think you’re a great singer, then belting out your favourite song isn’t a problem. However, if you think you must do it right or worry about what others think, you may be more hesitant to sing and this affects your feelings, mood and how you actually sound.
How does attitude affect the quality of mindfulness meditation? Well, if your attitude is ‘Mindfulness is really hard,’ then you try very hard to get somewhere. If your attitude is ‘Mindfulness is easy’ and you then struggle, you may begin to get frustrated. If your attitude is ‘I don’t know how it’ll go. I’m going to give it a good go and see what happens,’ you’re prepared for whatever arises.
Attitudes can become habits – both good and bad. And attitudes, like habits, aren’t easy to change. You need to work to improve your attitude. Begin by discovering your current attitudes towards mindfulness, stillness, silence and non-doing. Then, through understanding and effort, you can develop attitudes that are more conducive to a regular mindfulness practice.
Now, look at your answers. Do you notice any patterns? Are you very positive about the potential benefits of mindfulness? Are you negative about mindfulness? Or are you indifferent and do you just want to experiment, like being a scientist of your own mind?
Try to be non-judgemental towards your answers. See them as just the way things are. If you can’t help being caught up in thinking, ‘That’s good’ or ‘Oh, that’s a really bad attitude, what’s wrong with me?’, notice that too. Your mind is simply coming up with judgements.
This section contains the key foundational attitudes that provide a base from which you can build a strong mindfulness practice. These attitudes help you to handle difficult sensations and emotions, overcome feelings of lethargy and generate energy for taking action. Without these attitudes your practice may become stale and your intention may weaken, along with your power to pay attention in the present moment. Some helpful ways of approaching your practice are developed through experience; others are available right from the start.
Think of these key attitudes like strawberry seeds. If you’re hoping to taste the delicious strawberries, you need to plant the seeds and water them regularly. In the same way, you need to water your attitudes regularly, by giving them your mindful attention. Then you can enjoy the fruit of your efforts in the form of a sweet, delicious strawberry. I’m a sucker for strawberries.
Although the attitudes identified in this section seem separate, they feed into and support each other. Any one of these attitudes, pursued and encouraged to grow, inadvertently supports the others.
Acceptance turns out to be one of the most helpful attitudes to bring to mindfulness. Acceptance means perceiving your experience and simply acknowledging it rather than judging it as good or bad. You let go of the battle with your present-moment experience. For some people, the word ‘acceptance’ is off-putting–; replace it with the word ‘acknowledgement’, if you prefer.
For example, when you feel pain, whether it’s physical, such as a painful shoulder, or mental, such as depression or anxiety, the natural reaction is to try to avoid feeling the pain. This seems very sensible, because the sensation of physical or mental pain is unpleasant. You ignore it, distract yourself, or perhaps even go so far as turning to recreational drugs or alcohol to numb the discomfort. This avoidance may work in the immediate short term, but before long, avoidance fails in the mental and emotional realm.
By fighting the pain, you still feel the pain, but on top of that, you feel the emotional hurt and struggle with the pain itself. Buddha called this the ‘second arrow’. If a warrior is injured by an arrow and unleashes a series of thoughts like, ‘Why did this happen to me?’ or ‘What if I can never walk again?’ that’s a ‘second arrow’. You may inflict this on yourself each time you feel some form of pain or even just a bit of discomfort, rather than accepting what has happened and taking the next step. Avoidance – running away – is an aspect of the ‘second arrow’ and compounds the suffering. Acceptance means stopping fighting with your moment-to-moment experience. Acceptance removes that second arrow of blame, criticism or denial.
A useful formula to remember is:
Suffering = Pain x Resistance
The more your resist the pain you’re experiencing, the more you suffer. The pain is already there. Resisting the pain compounds your difficulties. Acceptance teaches you to let go of the resistance and therefore ease your suffering.
Perhaps you meditate and feel bombarded by thoughts dragging you away again and again. If you don’t accept the fact that your mind likes thinking, you become more and more frustrated, upset and annoyed with yourself. You want to focus on your mindfulness practice, but you just can’t.
In the above example:
By acknowledging the feeling, thought or sensation and going into it, the experience changes. Even with physical pain, try experimenting by actually feeling it. Research has found that the pain reduces.
But remember, you’re not acknowledging it to get rid of the feeling. That’s not acceptance. You need to try to acknowledge the sensation, feeling or thought without trying to change it at all – pure acceptance of it, just as it is.
Maybe even relax into the discomfort. One way to relax into the discomfort is by courageously turning to the sensation of discomfort and simultaneously feeling the sensation of your own breath. With each out-breath, allow yourself to move closer and soften the tension around the discomfort.
If all this acceptance or acknowledgement of your pain seems impossible, just try getting a sense of it and make the tiniest step towards it. The smallest step towards acceptance can set up a chain of events ultimately leading towards transformation. Any tiny amount of acceptance is better than none at all.
Another aspect of acceptance is to come to terms with your current situation. If you’re lost, even if you have a map of where you want to get to, you have no hope of getting there if you don’t know where you are to start with. You need to know and accept where you are. Then you can begin working out how to get to where you want to be. Paradoxically, acceptance is the first step for any radical change. If you don’t acknowledge where you are and what’s currently happening, you can’t move on appropriately from that point.
Helen Keller, the American deaf-blind political activist, is quoted as saying: ‘We could never learn to be brave and patient if there were only joy in the world.’ The quote makes a valid point. If every time you practised mindfulness, you were filled with joy and peace, you wouldn’t need that wonderful attitude of patience. The reality is that challenging thoughts and emotions sometimes arise in mindfulness, like in any activity. The important thing is how you meet and welcome those feelings.
Although you can experience the benefits of mindfulness after a short period of time, research shows that the more time you dedicate to cultivating mindfulness, the more effective the result. Mindfulness meditation is a training of the mind and training takes time.
When having a conversation with someone, spend more time listening rather than speaking. Let go of your initial urge to speak, and listen more. Listening can take tremendous effort, and is excellent patience training. Each time you practise, you train your brain to become slightly more patient.
Seeing afresh is normally referred to as the beginner’s mind, a term that was first used by the Zen master Suzuki Roshi. He once said: ‘In the beginner’s mind there are many possibilities, but in the expert’s there are few.’ What does that mean?
Consider a young child. Children, if they’re fortunate enough to be brought up lovingly, are the greatest mindfulness teachers in the world! They’re amazed by the simplest thing. Give babies a set of keys, and they stare at them, notice the wide range of colours reflected in them, shake them and listen to the sound – and probably giggle too. Then, of course, they taste the keys!
Children epitomise the beginner’s mind. They see things as if for the first time, because they’re not filled with ideas, concepts, beliefs, names or thoughts about the right or wrong thing to do. Babies don’t intellectualise. They connect with the raw sensory data entering their minds and they love it. Young children are naturally mindful, and that mindfulness is a true joy for them.
When you experience the state of the beginner’s mind, you live in a world of fascination, curiosity, creativity, attention and fun. You’re continuously discovering and looking out with the eyes of a child. You’re in ‘don’t know’ mind. When you think, ‘I know what’s going to happen’ or ‘I know what the breath feels like,’ you stop looking. You don’t know what’s going to happen; you just think you do. Each moment is fresh. Each moment is different and unique. Each moment is the only moment you have.
If you’re a beginner at mindfulness, you’re in an enviable position. You really are in the beginner’s mind! However, by the time you practise your second mindfulness meditation, you may begin comparing it with your first one and think, ‘It was better last time’ or ‘Why can’t I concentrate now?’ or ‘This is it. I’ve got it!’. You start to compare, conceptualise or condemn. When this happens, try to let it go – as much as you can – and bring your attention back to the here and now, as if you’re engaging in this for the very first time. I’m not saying that the beginner’s mind is an easy attitude, but it’s fundamental to sustaining a long-term meditative discipline.
Without a certain degree of trust, mindfulness meditation is challenging. This is because trust helps you to continue believing in the process of mindfulness when you feel that nothing’s happening or something ‘wrong’ is happening. For example, if you’re meditating and you suddenly feel bored, you need to trust that this is just another feeling, and that by continuing to practise mindfulness, that feeling may go away or it may not. Or, you may find that by the end of a mindfulness practice, you feel a bit worse than when you started. Without trust, you won’t be able to see that this is just a temporary experience which, like all experiences, won’t last forever.
Einstein was a master of curiosity. He thought that curiosity was an essential part of a fulfilling life. Einstein is quoted as saying:
‘The important thing is not to stop questioning. Curiosity has its own reason for existing. One cannot help but be in awe when he contemplates the mysteries of eternity, of life, of the marvellous structure of reality. It is enough if one tries merely to comprehend a little of this mystery every day. Never lose a holy curiosity.’
Curiosity is the basis of all true learning. If you’re curious, you want to find out something new: you want to gain some new knowledge. A curious person is fully connected with her senses. If you’re curious, you look around intently and earnestly to see something you haven’t seen before. You ask lots of questions, both of yourself and others. These can be questions like, ‘Why is the sky blue?’ or ‘Why is that shadow over there faint, whereas this one is much darker?’. Or it may be questions about yourself, like ‘I wonder why I feel tired after eating X?’ or ‘Where do thoughts come from?’ or ‘What happens to the feeling of frustration if I try to feel it in my body and breathe into it?’.
Bringing curiosity to your mindfulness practice is especially helpful. In fact, with curiosity, mindfulness automatically arises: you naturally begin to pay attention and, with a sense of wonder, to notice what’s happening. Take the example of thought: if you’re really curious about the types of thoughts that you have over a period of ten minutes, you pay attention and watch thoughts in your mind as best you can. That’s mindfulness. If your curiosity is genuine, you’ll probably keep watching those thoughts until that curiosity is satisfied.
I could go on and on with thousands of questions to ask. Try to come up with some of your own; your own curiosity is more powerful than anything I give you.
Ask yourself a question and investigate. Feed your curiosity and see what you discover. Allow your curiosity to spread from your mindfulness practice to your day-to-day living. Become curious about your thoughts, emotions and physical sensations rather than just ignoring them or trying to instantly change them.
Experimenting with doing things differently is a great way to fuel your curiosity and increase your mindfulness. For example, today I thought, ‘How can I brush my teeth in a different way, just for fun?’. The answer came: stand on one leg. So I brushed my teeth while balancing on one leg. I was surprised at how much more mindful I was. Rather than automatically brushing and letting my mind wander, I was conscious of keeping my balance. You probably think I’m mad – perhaps you’re right! But the point I’m trying to make is that if you do things differently that immediately makes life a bit more fun and a bit more mindful too. What can you do differently today?
Imagine I told you to hold a glass of water absolutely still. In fact, imagine I said that I’d give you whatever you wanted if you held the glass of water perfectly still. You’d probably try very hard and the glass might look quite still, but if you or anyone else looked really carefully at the water, you’d notice that it was still moving. I suspect that the harder you tried to hold the glass still, the more you’d shake it as you felt more worried or nervous about being 100 per cent still. The best way for the glass of water to be still would be for you to let it go and put it down on a solid surface. Then the water would stop moving.
Nature has many beautiful examples of letting go. Apple trees need to let go of their fruit so that the seeds inside can germinate. Animals need to let go of their young so they can find out how to fend for themselves. Young birds need to let go of any fear they feel when they first jump off a branch to begin to fly. You’re always letting go of each breath of air to make room for the next one. This last example shows that you naturally know how to let go all the time, in one sense. Remember this the next time you’re struggling to let go.
Letting go is the essence of mindfulness. Thoughts, emotions, ideas, opinions, beliefs, emotions and sensations are all to be observed, explored and then let go. If you’re struggling to understand or practise mindfulness, try letting go. Just gently practise as best you can and see what you discover – you’ll be on the right track.
How do you let go? Imagine you’re holding a tennis ball in your hands, and you’re asking me how to let go. Letting go isn’t something you do. Letting go is about stopping the doing. To let go of something, you stop holding onto it. The first step is to realise you’re holding onto the object in the first place. If you’re walking around holding a tennis ball, you can’t let go if you don’t know that the ball is in your hands. Once you know that the ball is there and feel the tension in your hands, you automatically let go.
Kindness is my religion.
Dalai Lama
This is one of the most important of all attitudes you can bring to your mindfulness practice. Your awareness of your breath, or your body or sounds, or whatever you’re paying attention to, can have a quality to it. The quality can be cold, harsh and incisive, or it can be warm, kind, friendly, forgiving, caring, gentle – in other words, loving. By bringing a sense of friendliness to your experience, the experience – whether it’s pleasant, unpleasant or neutral – is transformed.
Because kindness is such an important attitude, I go into this in more detail in the next section.
Figure 4-1 is the tree of mindfulness. The growth and development of the tree of mindfulness represents your own inner capacity to be mindful. Watering the roots represents the effort you make to cultivate the mindful attitudes and practise mindfulness. The fruit represent the benefits you naturally gain from the effort you put into being mindful. ‘As you sow, so shall you reap’ is the essence of mindfulness; this is why the fruit from your own tree of mindfulness is the same as the roots.
Over time, as you continue to look after the tree of mindfulness within you, the tree strengthens and matures. Your roots grow deep into the earth and your tree stands firmly earthed to the ground, offering shade to those around quite naturally. Mindfulness is firmly established within your being.
With attentiveness, a marksman can shoot an innocent person, a thief can plot a bank robbery, and a drug baron can count his money. But this isn’t true mindfulness – mindfulness isn’t pure attention alone. In Eastern language, the word for mind and heart is often the same, which is heartfulness. Instead of Mindfulness For Dummies, this book could just as easily be called Heartfulness For Dummies. Heartfulness is giving attention to anything that you can perceive with a sense of warmth, kindliness and friendliness, and thereby avoid self-criticism and blame.
Gratitude is considered by some as the greatest of all emotions that can be cultivated. Recent studies are beginning to show that gratitude has a unique relationship with wellbeing, and can explain aspects of wellbeing that other personality traits cannot. An attitude of gratitude goes hand in hand with mindfulness.
You’re grateful when you’re aware of what you do have rather than what you don’t. The effect of this is an opening of the heart. When you’re aware with an open heart, you’re in a deeper mindful mode.
Life has its difficulties. And you’re bound to get hurt by others, often wrongly so. The danger comes when you carry this hurt around with you. If you don’t let the emotional pain go, the next time something hurts you, the suffering accumulates. Over a period of years, the hurt can feel like you’re walking around carrying a heavy sack everywhere you go. Your shoulders feel tense. Your face is screwed up. You’re tense and uptight.
This harmful state of mind requires forgiveness for you to feel happier. Being annoyed with someone else hurts you rather than anyone else. You may admire hearing about others forgiving in situations of hatred, but when you’re called upon to do so yourself, you’re stuck. You may find yourself feeling angry, depressed or hateful. Many studies now show that releasing and letting go of past hurts through forgiveness leads to a longer and happier life.
Forgiveness doesn’t mean what the other person did to you was right or okay. It means you’re willing to let that go so you can move on and live a happier life. Forgiveness is an act of kindness towards yourself. And through that self-kindness, you naturally become a nicer person to be with for others too.
With time and practice, you may feel a shift in your heart and be able to forgive. If the shift doesn’t happen, notice how you feel, and be soft and kind with yourself. Let the forgiveness be genuine. Forgiveness takes time, so be patient and practise the meditation regularly. With regular commitment, you’ll be able to release yourself from the sorrow you’re carrying, through gentle forgiveness.
Just as you have helpful attitudes to cultivate in your mindfulness practice, you also have unhelpful attitudes that you’d be better off staying away from. For example, if you’re a bit of a perfectionist and are worried you’re going to fall asleep in your mindfulness practice, you don’t need to start panicking, or worrying when you start struggling to stay awake. You just need to become aware of the perfectionist mindset and, as best you can, let the unhelpful approach go.
If you want a quick fix for all your problems, you’ve come to the wrong place. Mindfulness is simple but not easy. Mindfulness is a powerful process that takes time, and a certain type of effort, energy and discipline. You can find quick fixes in the domain of television advertising, billboards and the Internet. I know these temptations are great, and marketing companies spend billions to work out how to convince you to part with your hard-earned cash. Unfortunately, however, in my limited experience of instant happiness, that form of happiness is just that: instantly present and instantly gone.
What you can do is integrate mindfulness practices into your life in short bursts. You don’t have to sit for hours and hours in the lotus posture. One minute of mindful attention on your breath on a daily basis can begin to shift something within you. The more you put in, the more you get out. Five minutes is better than one minute. You need to decide what’s right for you: trust in yourself to make a decision and stick to that choice for a period of time.
‘I’ll meditate as soon as I’ve sorted my life out.’ ‘I’ll do the course when things are totally settled.’ ‘I’ll practise mindfulness when I have no more problems in my life.’ These excuses are common and, on the whole, unconstructive. Sometimes you do need to allow major events in your life to settle before you work on a new skill like mindfulness. However, you can’t wait for life to become perfect. You don’t have time to waste. If you’ve found a way to systematically and thoroughly create a meaningful way of producing further health and wellbeing in your life, why not take the first step? Yes, you may get it wrong and make mistakes, but imperfection, mistakes and stumbles are an integrated part of the process of finding out about anything. No child ever began to walk without falling. No driver ever learns to drive without stalling. Take the first step today.
Failures are finger posts on the road to achievement.
CS Lewis
If you’re struggling a lot in your mindfulness practice, you’re probably holding onto a desire for something. Maybe you desire to get rid of tension, a feeling of irritation, your mind wandering, or boredom. Maybe you’re trying to get peace of mind, focus or relaxation. Make peace with your mindfulness practice. Let go of your desire to get anything out of the practice. Then, paradoxically, you’ll find the practice far more enjoyable and peaceful.