Many published value charts group the grays too close together at the beginning and end of the scale. The object is to create a discernible difference between each step. The 4 & 5 Value Chart shows two steps between each grade. These were made with animation cel paint and the numbers indicate their numerical listing.
VALUE CHARTS
1. Local Tone
2. Patchwork
3. Harlequin
4. Soft Light
5. Hard Light
6. Light-Struck
1. Local tone is easy and common. It is the starting place.
2., 3., 6. Patchwork, Harlequin and Light-Struck promise the highest returns for their use. They can all be used in combinations with local tone.
4., 5. Soft and Hard Light is used sparingly.
Soft Light and Hard Light are the least appropriate schemes for stylized characters. The emphasis they put on the third dimension is contrary to surface décor.
5. Hard Light is the toughest to do. Intense color is virtually ruled out in it.
Shadows need to be as continuous as possible. Tone contrast between local tones is minimized in shadow and cut back in light. Shadows need to be neutralized with complements or black.
To get any intensity in lighted tones the major background and other tones must be neutralized.
Pure Color and Hard Light Chiaroscuro is a contrarium.
A lit dark object against a shadowed light object creates a problem. Vermeer makes the shadow darker than the lit dark object.
1., 2., 3., 4., 5., 6. Because of the many close tones required in a Tone-Scheme approach, gouache is indicated to give another dimension of contrast: opaque/transparent and warm/cool (plus use of white).
Merging shadow with light tie-ins is 3 (Harlequin) and 6 (Light-Struck) together and pushed into a (compound-form) Compound-Notan Patchwork.