CHAPTER 7
Employee Compensation
Salary, Wages, and Employee Benefits

  1. Worker Classification
  2. Temporary Workers and Outsourced HR
  3. Deductible Employee Compensation
  4. Compensation to Owners
  5. Stock Options and Restricted Stock
  6. Deferred Compensation
  7. Disallowance Repayment Agreements
  8. Employee Benefits
  9. Identity Theft Protection
  10. Nonstatutory Fringe Benefits
  11. Cafeteria Plans
  12. Employment Tax Credits

If  you are an employee of someone else's business, you do not pay compensation to another individual. You can skip most of this chapter and go on to look at other deductible expenses. However, you might want to review the areas covered to understand your employer's burdens and responsibilities for the wages and benefits paid to you. You may also be interested in a couple of tax credits to which you may be entitled by virtue of working.

If you are the owner of a sole proprietorship, partnership, or limited liability company, you are not an employee and cannot receive employee compensation. Money you take out of your business is a “draw,” but it is not a deductible expense for the business (you already pay tax on your share of business income, whether or not it is distributed to you). However, your business may have employees, and payments to them are deductible according to the rules discussed in this chapter. According to the Winter 2016 Statistics of Income Bulletin, wages and compensation along with commissions was the largest deduction type for sole proprietorships (other than cost of goods sold and depreciation); only car and truck expenses was a larger category.

As a business owner, you need to understand a number of matters related to compensation: how to properly classify workers, the rules for deducting compensation to employees, the rules for claiming employment-related tax credits, and payroll obligations for employers.

Also discussed in this chapter are the earned income credit and the dependent care credit. These are not business credits; rather, they are personal credits that arise by virtue of employment. The earned income credit is a refundable credit for low-income householders, and the dependent care credit is designed to offset the costs of babysitting and other dependent-related expenses incurred to allow parents to work.

Employment taxes on compensation you pay to your employees, including federal income tax withholding, FICA (Social Security and Medicare taxes), FUTA (federal unemployment tax), and state taxes (income, unemployment, and disability), are discussed in Chapter 29.

Medical coverage is an important facet of employee compensation. It is also a necessary item for self-employed individuals. Medical coverage for you and your employees is explained in Chapter 19.

For further information about employee compensation, see IRS Publication 334, Tax Guide for Small Business; IRS Publication 15, Circular E, Employer's Tax Guide; IRS Publication 15-A; Employer's Supplemental Tax Guide; and IRS Publication 15-B, Employer's Guide to Fringe Benefits.

Worker Classification

In order to know whether payments to workers are wages, you must first determine whether the workers are employees or independent contractors. This is a hot issue for the IRS because there are substantial tax dollars at stake. The IRS believes that as many as 30% of workers are erroneously treated as independent contractors, which costs the government $7 billion in revenue. The issue, however, goes beyond the IRS and concerns the Department of Labor (because wage and hour laws apply to employees but not to independent contractors) and the National Labor Relations Board (because only employees can be unionized). For example, there's a raging controversy about Uber drivers: Are they employees or independent contractors? State labor departments are also concerned with correct worker classification because only employees can claim unemployment benefits and workers’ compensation.

A worker is treated as an employee if your company exercises sufficient control over when, where, and how the work gets done. If you control only the final results, the worker may be an independent contractor. The key to worker classification is control. In order to prove independent contractor status, you, as the employee, must show that you do not have the right to control the details and means by which the work is to be accomplished. You may also want to show that the worker has an economic stake in the work (that the worker stands to make a profit or loss depending on how the work turns out). It is helpful in this regard for the worker to supply tools and place of work, although working from home, using his or her own computer, and even setting hours (flex time) are not conclusive factors that preclude an employee classification. Various behavioral, financial, and other factors can be brought to bear on the issue of whether a worker is under your control. You can learn more about worker classification in IRS Publication 15-A, Employer's Supplemental Tax Guide and at www.irs.gov/Businesses/Small-Businesses-&-Self-Employed/Independent-Contractor-Self-Employed-or-Employee.

Misclassifying Workers

It is critical to note that the consequences for misclassifying workers can be dire for an employer. If you fail to treat a worker as an employee when you should do so, you are penalized for not withholding income taxes on wages and paying employment taxes. Penalties and interest in this regard can, in some instances, be enough to bankrupt your company. Misclassification can also wreak havoc with employee benefit plans, including retirement plans. If the IRS successfully reclassifies workers as employees, you will be required to provide back benefits (medical, retirement plan contributions, and other benefits you provided to your correctly classified employees).

You may be able to rely on a “safe harbor” rule (called Section 530 relief) to avoid employment tax penalties. (This relief provision is not in the Internal Revenue Code; it's from the Revenue Act of 1978.) At a minimum, if you want to treat workers as independent contractors, make sure you do so consistently and that you have a reasonable basis for doing so. The tax law considers these situations to be a reasonable basis:

  • You relied on a court case about federal taxes or a ruling issued to you by the IRS.

  • You have already gone through an IRS audit in which the issue of worker classification was raised and your workers were not reclassified.

  • A significant segment of your industry (at least 25%) treats such workers as independent contractors.

Require your independent contractors to complete Form W-9, Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification, a form on which they accept responsibility for paying their required taxes.

Also make sure you file the required information return for independent contractors (Form 1099-MISC) if the worker earned at least $600 (see Appendix A for details).

If the IRS questions your worker classification and you cannot prove your position on audit or resolve it through the classification settlement program, you can now bring your case to Tax Court for a determination. This means you do not have to pay the taxes up front to have your case reviewed in court.

VCSP. The IRS has a Voluntary Classification Settlement Program (VCSP) that allows companies to reclassify workers as employees with nominal penalties. As of March 2012 (the only available statistics), fewer than 1,000 applications had been made to the program (and no additional statistics are available). To qualify, you must not be under an audit by the IRS, must have issued required 1099s, and must meet other qualifications. You can choose to reclassify one group of workers while not reclassifying another. Before you request participation in this program, be sure to talk with a tax advisor. Participation protects you only from IRS audit on worker classification; it provides no protection from challenges by other government agencies (e.g., state labor departments examining a worker's claim for unemployment benefits or workers' compensation), third parties, or workers.

Temporary Workers and Outsourced HR

There are other ways to obtain workers who are not independent contractors and also are not your employees:

  • Temporary workers. If you engage someone through a temporary agency, such as Kelly Services or Manpower, the worker is the employee of the agency. The agency, and not you, is responsible for all employer obligations. You merely pay the agency a fee for the services (the deduction for this fee is explained in Chapter 22).

  • Outsourced HR. You may continue using existing employees, but shift employer obligations to an outside source. For example, a professional employer organization (PEO) effectively creates a co-employer situation. You have the right to hire and fire, but the PEO is responsible for all HR functions, including payroll taxes and insurance. Again, the PEO fee is deductible (see Chapter 22). Note that starting July 1, 2016, the IRS began accepting applications for PEO certification that will be granted following background checks and other verifications about the PEO; the certification shows that the PEO is reputable.

Deductible Employee Compensation

Compensation you pay to your employees can take many forms. In general, most types of compensation are fully deductible by you. Deductible compensation includes the more common forms, such as salary, wages, bonuses for services performed, vacation pay, sick pay (not otherwise paid by insurance), and fringe benefits, whether or not they are tax-free to your employee. In setting compensation, determine what you can afford and what your competitors are paying their workers. Understand that the law does not require you to offer paid leave for federal or state holidays, vacation, sick days, personal days, or other time off. As a rule of thumb, the average number of paid holidays is only 5 per year at firms with under 100 employees (on average for all firms in 2015 it was 9 paid holidays).

The deduction for these items must be reduced, however, by any employment tax credits claimed. These tax credits are discussed later in this chapter. The timing of when to deduct year-end bonuses paid after the end of the year is discussed in Chapter 2.

General Rules for Deductibility of Compensation

To be deductible, compensation must meet 5 tests. Test 1 requires that the compensation be an ordinary and necessary business expense. The payments must be directly connected to the conduct of your business, and they also must be necessary for you to carry on your business.

For test 2, the compensation must be reasonable. For most employees, this issue never comes up; it is assumed that pay to rank-and-flle employees is reasonable. The question of reasonableness typically arises in connection with pay to owners and top executives. There are no absolute guidelines for determining what is reasonable—it depends on the individual facts and circumstances. Ask yourself: “Would another business pay the same compensation under your circumstances?” If you are confident that the answer is yes, most likely the compensation is reasonable. To get an idea of what other companies are paying for comparable work, go to PayScale (www.payscale.com).

The IRS uses a number of factors to determine whether compensation is reasonable. These factors include:

  • The job description of the employee. What duties must the employee perform? How much responsibility does the employee shoulder? How much time is required to perform the job? How much business is handled by the employee?

  • The nature of the business. What are the complexities of your business? What has been your pay policy for all employees? What is the pay to a particular employee as compared with the gross and net profit of the business and distributions to shareholders?

  • The general cost of living in your locality. Formula-based compensation (such as a percentage of sales or some other fixed arrangement) may be reasonable if it is an industrywide practice to use these formulas.

Courts have also used a hypothetical independent investor standard to test reasonableness. Under this test, courts decide whether a disinterested investor would approve the compensation level in light of the dividends and return on equity. In determining reasonableness, you must look at the total compensation package and not merely the base salary. Also, each employee's pay package must be reasonable by itself. The fact that your total payroll is reasonable is not sufficient.

Remember, if compensation paid to an employee who is also an owner of the corporation is not reasonable, then it may be viewed as a constructive dividend to such an owner-employee. As such, the payment is not deductible by the corporation even though it is fully taxable to the owner. However, the owner-employee and corporation can enter into a disallowance repayment agreement to preserve deductibility. Such agreements are discussed later in this chapter.

Generally, it is up to you to prove the reasonableness of compensation. However, if the issue goes to court, the burden of proof shifts to the IRS once you have presented credible evidence of reasonableness. Only small businesses (corporations and partnerships whose net worth does not exceed $7 million) can shift the burden of proof to the IRS.

There are dollar limits on the deduction for reasonable compensation for certain types of executives, as explained in “Audit Strategies” later in this chapter. These dollar limits do not apply for small businesses.

Test 3 requires that the payment be for services actually performed. This issue does not generally arise for ordinary employees. However, in a family situation, the IRS may pay closer attention to see that work has actually been performed for the compensation paid. Thus, for example, if you employ your spouse, children, or parent, be sure to document their work hours and duties should your return be questioned. In one case, a parent was able to deduct salary paid to his 7-year-old son because he showed that the child performed meaningful tasks for his business. In another case, a parent who had her 3 children perform services in her home office, including photocopying, stuffing envelopes, and shredding, could not deduct their wages because she never actually paid them; merely buying things they wanted did not establish that they were paid. In several cases, a deduction for equal pay to both spouses was denied where one spouse was a professional (e.g., an engineer or a doctor) and the other performed only administrative and secretarial duties. The compensation to the professional might have been reasonable, but the same pay to the spouse clearly was not.

Guaranteed annual wages may be deductible as salary even though work is not performed. The deduction is limited to full-time guaranteed wages paid under a collective bargaining agreement.

Test 4 is that you must actually have paid the compensation if you are on the cash basis, or incurred the expense if you are on the accrual basis. Incurring the expense means that economic performance has occurred. For a complete discussion on economic performance, see Chapter 2. Again, a mother whose 3 children did office work at her law office could not deduct their pay because she couldn't show there had been any payment (no checks for payments to them, no W-2s were issued).

Test 5 applies to year-end bonuses and other payments by accrual basis businesses. Bonuses accrued before year-end cannot be deducted unless they are actually paid within a certain time. The time limit depends upon who is receiving the payment.

  • Rank-and-file employees—payment must be completed within 2½ months after the close of the year. For example, a bonus declared on December 24, 2016, by an accrual basis corporation for an employee who is not a shareholder must be paid by March 15, 2017, in order to be deductible in 2016. If you create a pot for bonuses to be divvied up among employees, you can deduct the lump sum as long as bonuses are paid within the 2½ month rule. However, if you reserve the right to alter bonus amounts or which employees are eligible to receive them, you cannot deduct the bonuses until actually paid.

  • Shareholders in C corporations—payments to those owning more than 50% of the stock cannot be deducted until actual payment is made. Shareholders who own 50% or less are considered rank-and-file employees for purposes of this rule.

  • Owners of pass-through entities—payments cannot be deducted until actual payment is made, regardless of the percentage of ownership. For example, a year-end bonus paid to an S corporation shareholder by an accrual basis corporation is not deductible until the bonus is actually paid.

Other Types of Deductible Compensation

Here are some less common, but equally deductible, compensation items:

  • Outplacement services provided to workers you have laid off. The types of outplacement services that are deductible include career counseling, resume assistance, skills assessment, and even the cost of renting equipment to facilitate these services.

  • Black Lung benefit trust contributions made by coal mine operators, provided the contributions are paid no later than the filing of the return (including extensions). The contribution must be made in cash (check) or property; a promissory note is not currently deductible.

  • Interest-free or below-market loans to employees. The amount of interest not charged that is less than the applicable federal interest rate (a rate that changes monthly and depends on whether the loan is short-term, mid-term, or long-term) is treated as compensation. The employer includes that same amount as taxable interest.

  • Severance pay. If you are forced to downsize your work force or otherwise let employees go, you may offer them some benefits package. The IRS has acknowledged that severance pay generally is deductible as an ordinary and necessary business expense even though an argument could be made that it provides some future benefit (which would suggest capitalizing the cost). However, if severance pay is part of a plan, method, or arrangement deferring the receipt of income, then it is deductible only when it is included in the worker's income (whether or not the employer is on the cash or accrual method of reporting).

  • Salary continuation. If you want to continue paying wages to an owner-employee who becomes disabled and to claim a deduction for such payments, do so under a salary continuation plan that you set up for this purpose. Without such a plan in place, you risk having the IRS label the payments as dividends or withdrawals of capital, neither of which are deductible by the company.

  • Director's fees. A corporation's payment of fees to its directors is deductible, but such fees are not treated as compensation even if the director is also an officer or other employee of the corporation. The fees are deductible as other business expenses (see Chapter 22).

  • Employment agency fees. If you pay a fee to an employment agency or headhunter to hire an employee, you may deduct the cost as another business expense.

  • Incentives for special vehicle purchases. If you offer employees a cash payment or other incentive so they buy a hybrid or electric vehicle rather than a standard vehicle, the amount is treated as additional compensation; it is deductible by you and taxable to the employee.

Other Limits on Deducting Compensation

Besides the reasonable compensation and other tests discussed earlier, there are several limitations on deducting compensation.

  • Deferred compensation. If your employee agrees to defer compensation to some future date, such as retirement, you cannot claim a deduction until such time as the employee includes the compensation in his or her income. This is true for accrual method businesses as well as cash basis businesses.

  • Prizes and awards. You can deduct prizes and awards you pay to employees, but only certain ones are tax free to them. An employee achievement award is tangible personal property given for an employee's length of service or safety achievement, which is awarded as part of a meaningful presentation and under conditions and circumstances that do not create a significant likelihood of disguising the award as compensation. An award is not considered a length-of-service award if made within the first 5 years of employment. An award is not considered a safety achievement award if it is given to a manager, administrator, clerical employees, or other professional employee, or if it is given to more than 10% of employees (other than those just listed). Awards can be qualified or nonqualified; the difference impacts what is tax free to employees. A qualified achievement award is one given under a written plan that does not discriminate in favor of highly compensated employees as to eligibility or benefits; it is fully tax free. A nonqualified achievement award, which does not meet the definition of a qualified achievement award, is tax free to an employee as long as it does not exceed $400 per year and total awards (qualified and nonqualified) made to any one employee do not exceed $1,600.

  • Vacation pay by accrual basis employers. Vacation pay earned by an employee is deductible in the current year only if you actually pay it out by the close of the year or within 2½ months of the close of the year. If you fail to pay it out within this time frame, it becomes deductible in the year it is actually paid out. Of course, for cash basis employers, vacation pay is deductible as wages when it is paid to an employee.

Noncash Payments

In some cases, you may pay your employees with property instead of cash. What is the amount you deduct? Your cost for the property (basis), or its value at the time it is paid to employees? You can deduct only your basis in the property, even though its value is included in the employee's income as compensation and employment taxes are based on this value.

Payments in virtual currency (e.g., Bitcoin) are treated as payments in property, not cash. You have to determine the value of the Bitcoin payment in order to claim a deduction for making the payment.

Restricted Property

If you transfer stock or other property that is subject to restrictions to an employee in payment for services, you generally cannot deduct the expense until such time as the stock or other property is no longer subject to restrictions. Restrictions include limits on transferring the stock or property. The term also covers property that is not substantially vested in the employee.

When and how much you can deduct for this type of compensation depends on a number of factors, such as the kind of property transferred and when the property is included in the employee's gross income. In the past, an employer could deduct restricted property only when such property was subject to withholding. Sometimes this was impossible, because a worker was no longer in the employer's employment. The IRS has eased its position and has dropped the withholding requirement. The property must still be included in the worker's income in order for the employer to claim a deduction. According to the IRS, the worker will be deemed to have included the amount in income in the year for which an employer complies with W-2 reporting requirements.

Compensation to Owners

How much should you pay yourself? What are the tax ramifications? The answers depend on your business's financial situation, your personal needs, how the business is organized, and more.

Employee versus Self-Employed

If your business is a corporation, whether C or S, you are an employee if you provide services for the corporation. Compensation is deductible by the corporation and taxable to you. Compensation is subject to Social Security and Medicare (FICA) taxes, and the additional Medicare tax of 0.9% if compensation exceeds a threshold amount for your filing status ($200,000 for singles; $250,000 for joint filers; $125,000 for married persons filing separately).

In contrast, if you are a self-employed person because your business is a sole proprietorship, partnership, or limited liability company, you do not receive compensation. Instead, you can take a draw, which can be fixed to appear like a salary. The draw is not deductible by the company; it is not separately taxable to you (it is part of the net earnings from the business on which you are taxed). The draw is not separately subject to self-employment tax (which is effectively the employer and employee share of Social Security and Medicare taxes). Instead, self-employment tax is paid on all of the net earnings allocated to the owner (with some modifications), regardless of whether earnings are paid out (as draw or otherwise) or retained by the business. Net earnings from self-employment over your applicable threshold amount (the same threshold that applies to employees described earlier) is subject to the 0.9% additional Medicare tax; the amount of your draw has no impact on whether and to what extent this tax applies to you.

Guaranteed payments to partners are different from a draw. These payments are made for services without regard to the income of the partnership. The payments are deductible by the partnership (before determining partnership profit or loss), are treated as ordinary income to the recipient-partner, and generally are subject to self-employment tax.

Audit Strategies

The compensation payment strategy varies for C and S corporations.

  • C corporations. The general approach is to maximize compensation to create large tax deductions for the business. Deductible compensation cannot exceed what is reasonable under the circumstances; what is reasonable is a highly litigated issue in tax law. Whereas public corporations can deduct compensation to certain employees only up to $1 million ($500,000 for the top 5 executives in medical insurance companies and companies directly assisted by the government under the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act) (provided this is reasonable) and up to $500,000 for compensation paid to service providers of a covered health insurance provider (CHIP), other C corporations do not have any dollar limit on deductible compensation.

  • S corporations. The general approach is to minimize compensation to reduce FICA taxes for the corporation and owner. The owner pays income tax on all of the net earnings allocated to him or her, but FICA tax applies only to amounts distributed as compensation. Some owners have opted to take no compensation in order to avoid any FICA tax, but courts have said that owners must receive at least some compensation for work performed (essentially what the corporation would have to pay a third party to do the same work). The IRS has identified the lack of compensation to S corporation owner-employees as a key audit target.

Stock Options and Restricted Stock

If your business is incorporated, you can give or sell to employees (including owner-employees) the right to buy shares in the corporation. They can be a useful form of compensation when the business does not have cash on hand. Of course, when the options are exercised and employees obtain stock, this dilutes the ownership interests of previously existing shareholders.

There are 2 types of options: (1) qualified stock options, which are incentive stock options (ISOs) and options granted under an employee stock purchase plan (usually used only in large corporations and not discussed any further here), and (2) nonqualified employee stock options.

ISOs. From the employee perspective, income is recognized not when the option is granted or exercised, but only when the stock acquired pursuant to the option is sold (provided certain holding periods are met). However, the exercise of an ISO may be an adjustment for purposes of the alternative minimum tax (see Chapter 28).

From the employer perspective, because employees do not have income from the ISO at the time it is granted or exercised, there is no compensation deduction at that time. However, if there is a disqualifying disposition of the stock acquired, the disposition creates compensation income for the employee, which is the difference between the strike price and the stock's fair market value (FMV) at the time of exercise. A disqualifying disposition is a disposition of the stock within either 2 years from the date that the option is granted or one year from the date that the option is exercised.

Nonqualified employee stock options. From the employee perspective, the nonqualified stock option is taxable to the employee at the time it is granted if it has a “readily ascertainable fair market value.” For closely held corporations, this means the option can be transferred and/or exercised immediately, without restrictions or conditions. If there is no such value, then the employee is taxed when the option is exercised.

The employee can make what is called a Section 83(b) election to report the income when the option is exercised but the stock is not vested (there are restrictions or conditions to transferring the stock), even if he or she is not otherwise required to do so. This election allows an employee to convert what would be ordinary income into capital gain; by reporting some ordinary income now, all future appreciation becomes capital gain. The election must be made within 30 days of receipt of the restricted stock. The election can be on the IRS sample form (Form 7.1) or on the employee's own statement (there is no IRS form for this), which is filed with the IRS service center in which the employee files his or her return; provide a copy to the employer-corporation.

From the corporation's perspective, a deduction for the value of the nonqualified stock option can be claimed when the option is included in the employee's gross income as compensation. This occurs when the option is granted if the option has a readily ascertainable value (something very rare in closely held corporations). If the option does not have a readily ascertainable value, the corporation's deduction is postponed until the employee exercises the option, provided the employee's rights in the stock are vested. If rights in the stock are not vested, then the deduction is further postponed until such rights are vested. The deduction at this time is the amount of income that the employee recognizes (i.e., the value of the stock minus the strike price and any amount paid by the employee, or the net amount received by the employee in exchange for the option).

Form of section 83(b) election has spaces to fill taxpayer’s name, social security number et cetera to fill the relevant entries.

FORM 7.1  

When an employee exercises the option, you as the employer must report to the employee and the IRS the excess of the fair market value of the stock over the amount that the employee paid for the stock. This reporting is done on the employee's W-2 form.

Deferred Compensation

Owners (and certain employees) may wish to defer the receipt of compensation to a future date. Often deferral is used for bonuses or special payments above a base salary. If the deferred compensation arrangement is done properly, the compensation is not taxed until it is received, postponing the tax on the earnings. Deferred compensation is also used as a way to create retirement income, since receipt is usually postponed until the person retires or leaves the company. The company generally cannot deduct the deferred compensation until it is paid to the employee, although a special rule applies to year-end bonuses paid by accrual-based companies within 2½ months after the close of the year, as explained earlier in this chapter.

Deferred compensation can be created under an agreement, arrangement, or plan set up by the company. Key points to making deferred compensation plans work for maximum tax advantage:

  • The employee must agree to defer the compensation before it is earned. Once earned, any deferred payments are immediately treated as taxable.

  • Receipt of deferred compensation must be postponed to a fixed date, such as separation from service.

  • The employer cannot segregate the deferred amounts; they must remain an unfunded promise of payment by the company and subject to the claims of the company's creditors.

Note: Even though compensation is deferred for income tax purposes, it may be subject to payroll taxes when earned (see Chapter 29). There is great uncertainty about tax rates in the future. From a planning perspective, owners may not want to defer compensation at this time if they believe tax rates will be higher when they expect to receive the deferred amounts.

Disallowance Repayment Agreements

If you are an employee of a corporation you own and a portion of your salary is viewed as unreasonable, the corporation loses its deduction for the payment. You are taxed on the payment in any event—either as compensation or as a constructive dividend. However, there is a way you can ensure that the corporation does not lose out if the IRS later characterizes its compensation deduction as partially unreasonable: You can enter into a disallowance repayment agreement.

The repayment agreement provides that if certain payments to you by the corporation are disallowed by the IRS, you are required to repay such amounts to your corporation. The agreement must be in writing and enforceable under local law. The agreement should be reflected not only in a separate written agreement between you and your corporation, such as part of your employment contract with the corporation, but also in the corporate minutes as a resolution of the board of directors. The bylaws of the corporation should also reflect the ability of the board to enforce the agreement.

Effect of the Repayment Agreement

The repayment agreement is a way for you to offset dividend income you are required to report if the IRS considers payments to you to be constructive dividends. By virtue of the repayment agreement, you are entitled to deduct the amounts you are contractually required to repay to your corporation as a miscellaneous itemized deduction on your personal return in the year repayment is made. However, some tax experts do not think that a repayment agreement is a good idea. Having one could be viewed as an admission that the corporation expects to pay an unreasonable salary.

Employee Benefits

In General

Employers are not required by law to offer any specific types of employee benefits. However, in today's job market, employers may want to offer various fringe benefits (also called perks or perquisites) as a way of attracting and retaining a good work force. Businesses may also want to provide these benefits because owners want such benefits for themselves as well.

If you pay certain expenses for an employee, you can claim a deduction. This is so even though the benefits may be excluded from the employee's gross income. If you are a sole proprietor, partner, or LLC member, you are not an employee and cannot receive these benefits on a tax-free basis. For purposes of this rule, employees who are more than 2% shareholders in their S corporations are treated the same as partners and cannot get these benefits on a tax-free basis. Limits on benefits for sole proprietors, partners, LLC members, and more-than-2% S corporation shareholders are discussed later in this chapter.

The benefits provided to an employee must be ordinary and necessary business expenses. The cost of the benefits must be reasonable in amount. And, in most cases, the benefits must be provided on a nondiscriminatory basis; they cannot be extended only to owner-employees and highly paid workers.

There are 2 main categories of employee benefits. The first is called statutory employee benefits. These benefits, specifically detailed in the Internal Revenue Code, include health and accident plans, group term life insurance, dependent care assistance, adoption assistance, medical savings accounts, and cafeteria plans.

The other broad category of benefits is called nonstatutory fringe benefits. These refer to specific subcategories into which various miscellaneous benefits can fall. For example, if you provide your employees with a turkey at Christmas, this minimal benefit is classified as a de minimis fringe. It is not included in the employee's gross income even though you can claim a deduction for your cost of providing the benefit. Nonstatutory fringe benefits are discussed in greater detail later in this chapter.

Statutory Benefits

Certain types of plans or arrangements are treated as statutory benefits. The law details what constitutes a plan, which employees must be covered, the limits, if any, on the excludability of benefits, and other details.

Medical Insurance and Benefits

In general, medical insurance coverage, along with any reimbursements of medical expenses, is excluded from an employee's gross income. You deduct the cost of the medical insurance premiums. If you are self-insured (you reimburse employees for medical costs out of your operating expenses under a written medical reimbursement plan), you deduct reimbursements to the employees when and to the extent made. Medical coverage, including health savings accounts (HSAs), long-term care coverage, and medical reimbursement plans, is discussed more fully in Chapter 19.

Cellular Phones

If you give cell phones or smartphones to employees, you can deduct the cost of the phone and monthly service charges without employees reporting their business usage to you.

Personal usage of employer-provided phones to employees is not taxed to the employees if there is a noncompensatory reason for providing the phones. Examples of noncompensatory reasons:

  • The employer needs to contact the employee at all times for work-related emergencies.

  • The employer requires that the employee be available to speak with customers or clients at times when the employee is away from the office.

  • The employee needs to speak with customers or clients located in other time zones at times outside of the employee's normal workday.

Providing a phone to promote the morale or goodwill of an employee, to attract a prospective employee, or as a means of furnishing additional compensation to an employee is not providing the phone primarily for noncompensatory business purposes.

Dependent Care Assistance

Up to $5,000 may be excluded from an employee's gross income; your outlays are fully deductible. You must set up a program to provide this benefit—a plan that makes clear to your employees what they may be entitled to. You do not have to fund the plan (set money aside); instead you can pay as you go. However, as a practical matter, this benefit may not make sense for a small business since nondiscrimination rules intended to make sure that the plan does not favor owners prevents more than 25% of the amounts paid by the plan from benefiting owners (their spouses or dependents) who own more than 5% of the business.

You may allow your employees to pay for their own dependent care on a pretax basis by setting up a flexible spending arrangement (FSA) discussed later in this section.

For information about building child care facilities or offering child care referral services, see Chapter 23.

Group Term Life Insurance

You deduct the cost of providing this benefit, which is the cost of the premiums. Typical coverage runs 2 times or more of the annual salary of the employee. The cost for up to $50,000 of coverage is excludable from an employee's gross income. If coverage over $50,000 is provided, an imputed income amount for excess coverage is includible in the employee's gross income. The imputed income is calculated according to an age-based IRS table; it is not based on the actual cost of premiums. While you deduct the actual cost of providing this benefit, your employees will be pleased to learn that the income from excess coverage may be modest. Table 7.1 can be used to figure employee income from excess coverage that is reported on the employee's Form W-2. The amount shown is the cost per $1,000 of excess coverage each month.

Table 7.1 Employee Income from Excess Coverage

Age Imputed Income ($)
Under age 25 0.05
25–29 0.06
30–34 0.08
35–39 0.09
40–44 0.10
45–49 0.15
50–54 0.23
55–59 0.43
60–64 0.66
65–69 1.27
70 and older 2.06

The cost for up to $2,000 of coverage for spouses and dependents is also excludable from an employee's gross income as a de minimis fringe benefit. However, if this coverage exceeds $2,000, then all of the coverage (not just the amount above $2,000) is taxable to the employee.

If a group insurance plan is considered to be discriminatory, key employees (owners and top executives) will have income from the coverage and will not be able to exclude the cost for the first $50,000 of coverage. In this instance, income to them is the greater of the actual cost of the coverage, or the imputed amount calculated according to the age-based IRS tables. Special insurance coverage arranged on an individual basis (for example, split-dollar life insurance) is discussed later in this chapter.

Educational Expenses

If the courses are job related, your payments are deductible as noncompensatory business expenses. If the courses are not job related, your expenses are deductible as wages. If you lay off workers and pay for their retraining, you may also deduct your payments.

There is a special exclusion of up to $5,250 for employer-financed education assistance, including graduate-level courses, under a qualifying plan.

Amounts you pay for an employee under the plan can be excluded from the employee's income even if the courses are not job related. In that case, your payments under the plan would be deductible as noncompensatory business expenses.

As a practical matter, it is generally not advisable for owners of small businesses to set up educational assistance plans for the same reason that dependent care assistance programs may not make sense—no more than 5% of benefits can go to owner-employees or their spouses or dependents.

Adoption Assistance

You may deduct the cost of adoption assistance you provide to your employees. If you set up a special assistance program (a separate written plan to provide adoption assistance), your employees can exclude up to $13,460 per child in 2016. However, in 2016 the exclusion is phased out for those with adjusted gross income (AGI) between $201,920 and $241,920 (regardless of your filing status as married or single).

As in the case of educational assistance plans, adoption assistance plans do not make sense for small employers, since no more than 5% of benefits can go to owner-employees.

Retirement Planning Advice

If you maintain a qualified retirement plan, you can pay for expert advice for your employees and their spouses with respect to retirement planning, and they are not taxed on this benefit. There is no dollar limit to the exclusion. However, it does not apply to tax preparation, accounting, legal, or brokerage services. If you pay for these services on behalf of your employees, they are taxed on this amount, although you can deduct your payments.

Health Savings Accounts

If you maintain a high-deductible health insurance plan and contribute to a Health Savings Account (HSA) for an employee, you can deduct your contributions. Contribution limits and other rules for Health Savings Accounts are discussed in Chapter 19. Contributions are not taxed to employees and are exempt from payroll taxes. You must complete contributions by April 18, 2017, in order to deduct them on your 2016 return (even if you obtain a filing extension).

Note: If you are a small business or a self-employed individual, you can contribute to an Archer Medical Savings Account (MSA), assuming the account was set up prior to 2008.

HSAs and MSAs are discussed more fully in Chapter 19.

Health Reimbursement Accounts (HRAs)

These are plans under which an employee can draw up to a dollar limit fixed by the employer to cover out-of-pocket medical expenses. Until now, HRAs have been used to supplement employer-provided health coverage. These plans are discussed more fully in Chapter 19.

Cafeteria Plans and Flexible Spending Accounts

If you make contributions to cafeteria plans, you can claim a deduction as an employee benefit expense. Cafeteria plans are designed to offer employees choices among benefits on a nondiscriminatory basis. Simple cafeteria plans for small employers are explained later in this chapter.

Flexible spending accounts (FSAs) are also nondiscriminatory plans but are funded primarily with employee contributions. Flexible spending accounts are intended to cover medical costs or dependent care costs on a pretax basis. Employees agree to salary reductions (within limits set by law) that are then contributed to the FSA to be used for medical costs or dependent care costs. The dollar limit in 2016 on elective deferrals is $2,550 to medical FSAs and $5,000 for dependent care FSAs.

Generally, employee elective deferrals to FSAs are done on a use-it-or-lose-it basis. If qualified expenses for the year do not equal these amounts, contributions are lost. However, medical FSAs can add either of these features (but not both):

  • Carryover up to $500. The plan can allow unused amounts to be carried over to the following year. The carryforward is not cumulative, so that no more than $500 can ever be added to the basic elective deferral for the following year.

  • Grace period. The plan can allow unused amounts to be used within a period of up to 2½ months after the close of the year (March 15th).

From your perspective, however, you may be on the hook for payments if the plan pays out more than the employee has paid in and the employee then terminates employment. The reason: The plan must pay out benefits equal to the employees' annual commitment for salary reduction contributions, even if they have not been fully paid.


Other Employee Benefits

In addition to the various employee benefit plans just discussed, there are other types of benefits you may provide for employees for which you can claim a deduction for your expenses.

Supplemental Unemployment Benefits

If you make contributions to a welfare benefit fund to provide supplemental unemployment benefits for your employees, you may deduct your contributions as ordinary and necessary business expenses. The deduction is claimed as an employee benefit expense, not as a compensation cost. Your deduction cannot exceed the fund's qualified cost for the year. Qualified cost is the amount you could have claimed had you provided the benefits directly and been on the cash basis, plus the amount estimated to be actually necessary to build the fund to cover claims incurred but not yet paid and administrative costs for such claims.

Meals and Lodging

In general, the costs of providing meals and lodging to your employees are deductible as an expense of operating your business. The costs may or may not be taxable to your employees. The tax treatment of this benefit to your employees affects the amount and how you claim a deduction. Generally, you may deduct only 50% of the cost of providing meals.

The 50% limit on deducting meals does not apply if your employees must include the benefit in income. In this case, you may deduct 100% of the cost as compensation.

The 50% limit on deducting meals does not apply if you operate a restaurant or catering business and provide meals to your employees at your restaurant or work site. However, in this case, the full cost of the meals is not deductible as compensation; instead, it is treated as part of the cost of goods sold.



The 50% limit on meals does not apply if you provide the meals as part of the expense of providing recreational or social activities. For example, the cost of a company picnic is fully deductible.

You may deduct the full amount of meal costs if your employees are able to exclude this amount from their gross income. They do this if the meals are furnished on your premises and for your convenience, or if the meals qualify as a de minimis fringe benefit.

Special rules apply for valuing the meals provided at an employer-operated eating facility. An employer-operated eating facility is a lunchroom or other facility that you own or lease and operate directly or by a contract to provide meals on or near your business premises during or immediately before or after your employees’ workday. Meals provided at an eating facility on or near your business premises are treated as a de minimis fringe benefit. As such, they are excluded from your employee's income and you can claim a full deduction (you do not have to apply the 50% limit).

If you provide your employees with lodging on your premises (for example, if you run a motel, nursing home, or rental property and the employee must live on the premises in order to manage it), you may deduct your full expenses according to the particular expense involved. For example, you deduct the cost of heating and lighting as part of your utilities, the cost of bedding as part of your linen expenses, and the use of the room as a depreciation item.

However, if you are a self-employed individual, you cannot make your living costs tax deductible. You may not exclude them even if you live at your business (e.g., you own a motel and live in it) since you are not an employee of your business.

Housing Relocation Costs

While this may be rare, a small business may provide relocation assistance to an employee by helping with the sale of the employee's home. The business may deduct as “compensation” the payment of expenses related to the home where the employee retains the right to negotiate for a final sale price.

Travel and Entertainment Costs

If you pay for travel and entertainment costs, you may deduct your outlays, subject to certain limits. These expenses are explained in Chapter 6.

Employee Use of a Company Car

If you allow an employee to use a company car for personal purposes, you must value this personal use and include it in the employee's gross income. It is a noncash fringe benefit. There are several valuation methods for calculating personal use of a company car. The method to use depends on your particular circumstances.

One method is based on the actual fair market value (FMV) of the personal use. This is determined by looking at the cost of leasing a comparable car at a comparable price for a comparable period of time. The cost of the vehicle can be its FMV if the car was purchased in an arm's-length transaction. Under a safe harbor rule, you can use the manufacturer's invoice price (including the price for all options), plus 4%. Under another safe harbor rule, you can use the manufacturer's suggested retail price, minus 8%. Then find out what it would cost to lease a car of this value.

Another method is based on the car's annual lease value (ALV). The ALV is set by the IRS and depends on the FMV of the car on the date the car is first used for personal purposes (see Table 7.2).

Table 7.2 Annual Lease Value (ALV) Table for Cars

FMV ALV
     $0 to 999
 $ 600
 1,000 to  1,999
850
 2,000 to  2,999
 1,100
 3,000 to  3,999
 1,350
 4,000 to  4,999
 1,600
 5,000 to  5,999
 1,850
 6,000 to  6,999
 2,100
 7,000 to  7,999
 2,350
 8,000 to  8,999
 2,600
 9,000 to  9,999
 2,850
10,000 to 10,999
 3,100
11,000 to 11,999
 3,350
12,000 to 12,999
 3,600
13,000 to 13,999
 3,850
14,000 to 14,999
 4,100
15,000 to 15,999
 4,350
16,000 to 16,999
 4,600
17,000 to 17,999
 4,850
18,000 to 18,999
 5,100
19,000 to 19,999
 5,350
20,000 to 20,999
 5,600
21,000 to 21,999
 5,850
22,000 to 22,999
 6,100
23,000 to 23,999
 6,350
24,000 to 24,999
 6,600
25,000 to 25,999
 6,850
26,000 to 27,999
 7,250
28,000 to 29,999
 7,750
30,000 to 31,999
 8,250
32,000 to 33,999
 8,750
34,000 to 35,999
 9,250
36,000 to 37,999
 9,750
38,000 to 39,999
10,250
40,000 to 41,999 10,750
42,000 to 43,999 11,250
44,000 to 45,999 11,750
46,000 to 47,999 12,250
48,000 to 49,999 12,750
50,000 to 51,999 13,250
52,000 to 53,999 13,750
54,000 to 55,999 14,250
56,000 to 57,999 14,750
58,000 to 59,999 15,250

For cars over $59,999, calculate the ALV as follows: Multiply the fair market value of the car by 25% and add $500. The ALV figures apply for a 4-year period starting with the year of the ALV election. Thereafter, the ALV for each subsequent 4-year period is based on the car's then fair market value.

If the car is used continuously for personal purposes for at least 30 days but less than the entire year, you must prorate the value of personal use.

The ALV method already takes into account maintenance and insurance costs. Fuel provided by an employer is not included in the ALV. Fuel provided in kind can be valued at FMV or 5.5¢ per mile for purposes of including it in the employee's gross income. If fuel is paid by a company credit card, the actual charges are used to compute personal use included in the employee's gross income.

An employer may choose to treat all use by an employee of a company-owned car as personal use and include an appropriate amount in the employee's gross income. In this case, it is up to the employee to maintain records substantiating business use and then deduct such business use on his or her individual income tax return. If personal use of a company car is de minimis, then nothing need be included in the employee's gross income. As a practical matter, when the employee is an owner, the decision on how to value personal use of a company car is a mutual decision. Both the employer and employee in this case agree on which method is preferable. Keep in mind that when valuing personal use for an owner, only the fair market value or ALV methods can be used.

Another valuation method for personal use of a company car is the cents-per-mile special rule. This rule can be used only if a car is valued in 2016 at no more than $15,900 ($17,700 for a truck or van) and the car is regularly used in the business (at least 50% of total annual mileage is for the business, or the car is used each workday to drive at least 3 employees to and from work in a carpool) or for a car driven by employees at least 10,000 miles during a calendar year. And the employee cannot be a control employee (see below). If the car is owned or leased for less than a full year, the 10,000 miles are prorated accordingly. The value of personal use is based on the standard mileage rate. The standard mileage rate for 2016 is 54¢ per mile.

There is another method for valuing personal use of company vehicles called the fleet valuation method. This applies to companies with a fleet of 20 or more vehicles, something that small businesses do not have; this method is not explained further in this book.

If you want to use the ALV method or the cents-per-mile method, you must elect to do so. This election must be made no later than the first pay period in which the company car is used for personal purposes. You need not inform the IRS of your election.

Another method for figuring income to the employee for using a company car is the fixed and variable rate (FAVR) allowance. This is a reimbursement amount that includes a combination of payments covering fixed and variable costs, such as the cents-per-mile rate for variable operating costs (e.g., oil and gasoline) and a flat amount for fixed costs (e.g., depreciation or lease payments). The FAVR allowance is based on a standard automobile cost that cannot exceed $28,000 in 2016 ($31,000 for trucks and vans).

Commuting Vehicles

If you allow your employees to use company cars to commute to and from work, a special valuation rule is used to determine the amount includable in the employee's gross income. The car must be owned or leased by the employer for use in the business, and the employer must have genuine noncompensatory business reasons for requiring an employee to commute in the vehicle. Also, the employer must have a written policy preventing use of the vehicle for personal purposes other than commuting (or de minimis personal use). The employee cannot be a control employee (an employee who is a board-appointed, shareholder-appointed, confirmed, or elected officer with compensation of at least $50,000, a director, a 1% or greater owner, or someone who receives compensation of $100,000 or more). If the special commuting vehicle rule is met, then the value of commuting is $1.50 each way ($3.00 round trip), regardless of the length of the commute. The same flat rate applies to each employee even if more than one employee commutes in the vehicle. While the commuting vehicle rule is optional at the employer's election, it must be used for valuing all commuting if it is used for valuing any commuting.

The deduction for car expenses—depreciation, insurance, gas, oil, and repairs—is explained in Chapter 9. This chapter covers only business use of a company car.

Country Club Dues

If you pay the cost of membership at a golf or other country club, the dues are not deductible. However, an employee who uses the club for business can exclude the benefit from income (it is viewed as a working condition fringe benefit, explained, later even though country club dues are otherwise not deductible). However, you can convert this nondeductible cost of the business into a deductible expense by electing to treat the benefit as additional compensation to the employee—deducting the cost as compensation and not as an entertainment cost. This option is discussed more fully in Chapter 8.

Flights on Employer-Provided Aircraft

Special rules are used to determine the value of personal use of flights provided on employer aircraft. A discussion of these rules is beyond the scope of this book.

Life Insurance Provided on an Individual Basis

Businesses may provide owners and other top employees with coverage on an individual basis. This coverage may be term insurance or permanent insurance (e.g., a whole life policy). This coverage is taxable to the individual and does not have to be provided on a nondiscriminatory basis.

Split-Dollar Life Insurance

Under a split-dollar life insurance plan, the cost of coverage is shared between the business and the insured. Here is how the plan usually works.

A cash value life insurance policy is used for a split-dollar arrangement, with the business paying some or all of the premiums. At the death of the employee, the business recoups its outlay, and the balance of the proceeds is payable to the insured's beneficiary (typically his or her spouse or child). Under final regulations, how the employee is taxed on this benefit depends on who owns the policy:

  • If the employee owns the policy, premiums paid by the business are treated as loans, with imputed interest taxed to the employee.

  • If the business owns the policy, the employee is taxed on the value of the life insurance protection (which is the 1-year term cost of this protection).

In view of income tax being imposed on split-dollar life insurance arrangements, they are no longer favored as wealth builders for business owners.

Identity Theft Protection

If your company's computer data has been hacked, you may offer employees identity theft protection services (e.g., credit reports and credit monitoring, identity theft protection insurance, identity theft restoration services). The benefit is deductible by you and is tax free to employees.

If you offer these benefits in the absence of having data compromised (e.g., you do it to attract and retain valued employees), you can still deduct the benefit but it is taxable to employees and subject to employment taxes.

Nonstatutory Fringe Benefits

There is a special category of fringe benefits that you may provide to your employees on a tax-deductible basis but which your employees need not include in their income. These are referred to as nonstatutory fringe benefits because there is no separate section in the Internal Revenue Code for each particular benefit—they are all covered in the same section. Nonstatutory fringe benefits are not only excludable from the employee's gross income; they are also not subject to employment taxes. In general, these benefits must be provided on a nondiscriminatory basis. Benefits cannot be provided solely to owners and highly paid employees and not to rank-and-file employees. Nonstatutory fringe benefits include:

  • No-additional-cost service. You need not include in your employee's gross income the value of a service you offer to customers in the ordinary course of the business in which your employee works (e.g., if you run a ferry line and allow employees to ride for free on scheduled runs). In the case of no-additional-cost service, you generally do not have any expense to deduct by virtue of providing the benefit to the employee. You have already deducted costs related to providing the service.

  • Qualified employee discount. You need not include in your employee's gross income a price reduction you give on certain property or services you offer to customers in the ordinary course of your business in which the employee performs services (e.g., if you own a clothing boutique and give your salespersons a 15% discount on your merchandise). A qualified employee discount cannot exceed the price at which the item is ordinarily sold to customers multiplied by your gross profit percent (total sales price of property less cost of property, divided by total sales price of property) or 20% in the case of services.

       A qualified employee discount does not include any discount on real property. A deduction for the goods or services provided as a qualified employee discount is not taken into account as a compensation expense but rather as some other item. Goods provided to employees at a discount are part of the cost of goods sold.

  • Working condition fringe benefit. You need not include in your employee's gross income a benefit provided to your employee if the employee could have claimed his or her own deduction had he or she paid for the benefit. For example, if you paid for a job-related course that would have been deductible by your employee had the employee paid for it, the course is a working condition fringe benefit. Other examples of working condition fringe benefits include employer-provided vehicles and outplacement services.

  • De minimis (minimal) fringe. You need not include in your employee's gross income the value of any small or inconsequential benefits, such as the typing of a personal letter by a company secretary or the occasional use of the company copying machine for personal matters. Holiday gifts of nominal value, such as turkeys and hams, are considered de minimis fringes. However, cash of any amount is not a de minimis fringe and must be included in the employee's gross income. Other examples of de minimis fringes include group term life insurance for spouses and dependents up to $2,000 (discussed earlier in this chapter), meals furnished at an eating facility on or near your premises, coffee or soft drinks and donuts or apples furnished to employees in the break room, flowers or fruit baskets for special occasions, occasional tickets to sporting or entertainment events, occasional meal money or transportation fare for employees working overtime, and company events (such as parties or picnics) for employees and their guests.

  • Qualified transportation fringe benefit. If you provide your employee with a transit pass for mass transit, transportation in a commuter highway vehicle, or qualified parking, you need not include the benefit in your employee's gross income. The 2016 limit on the exclusion for these transportation fringe benefits is $255 per month. The value of parking is based on what a person would have to pay for space in an arm's-length transaction. If you provide parking space to employees that is primarily available to customers, then the parking has no value. If you give employees who carpool preferential parking, the value of the space must be taken into consideration. Employer-paid parking at a temporary job assignment—one expected to last one year or less that does in fact last that period—is fully excludable as paid under an accountable plan (explained in Chapter 8); there is no dollar limit in this situation. If the dollar limits are exceeded, only the excess is includible in gross income. However, in the case of partners, LLC members, and more-than-2% S corporation shareholders who are given public transit passes, the exclusion is limited to $21 per month. If the value of this exceeds the $21 per month limit, then the entire cost of the ticket is includible in the owner's gross income. The entire value of parking provided to partners and more-than-2% S corporation shareholders is taxable to them, even if it is less than $255 per month. There is another transportation fringe benefit for bicycle commuting of $20 per month to cover the cost of buying, maintaining, and storing a bicycle used to get to and from work. You can shift the cost of monthly transit passes to employees—they pay for the passes by means of salary reductions (i.e., pretax dollars); all you pay for is the administrative cost of handling the benefit. A bike-sharing program does not qualify as a transportation fringe benefit. The fact that you offer an employee a choice between a qualified transportation fringe benefit and cash does not make the benefit taxable if the employee chooses the benefit. The employee is, of course, taxed on cash received in lieu of the transportation fringe benefit.

  • Moving expenses. Payments to an employee (directly to the mover or as an allowance) for nondeductible moving expenses are deductible as wages and subject to employment taxes. Payments or reimbursements that would be deductible by the employee had the employee paid them are not treated as wages and are not subject to employment taxes. They are still deductible by you as noncompensatory business expenses. Moving expenses are explained further in Chapter 22.

  • Certain athletic facilities. You need not include in your employee's gross income the value of an on-site gym or other athletic facilities for use by employees, their spouses, and children. However, if you pay for a membership to an outside health club or athletic facility open to the general public, you must include the benefit in the employee's gross income. No deduction can be claimed for club dues (see Chapter 8).

Some companies allow employees to use business-generated frequent flyer mileage for personal purposes. This benefit defies classification and, to date, the IRS has not figured out a way to tax it without causing an administrative nightmare. However, the IRS has said it was going to take another look at taxing frequent flyer miles; to date it has not but check the Supplement for any update.

Limits on fringe benefits paid for the benefit of sole proprietors, partners, LLC members, and more-than-2% S corporation shareholders that are otherwise excludable by rank-and-file employees are taxable to sole proprietors, partners, LLC members, and more-than-2% S corporation shareholders. For example, if the business pays their health insurance (which may include long-term care insurance), the coverage is taxable to them. The business can deduct the costs as guaranteed payments to partners or as compensation to S corporation shareholders. Owners can then deduct the amount directly from gross income on page 1 of Form 1040.

The balance can be treated as a deductible medical expense, which is taken as an itemized deduction subject to the applicable adjusted-gross-income floor. Medical coverage for these owners is discussed in Chapter 19.

Cafeteria Plans

A cafeteria plan is a written plan that allows your employees to choose to receive cash or taxable benefits instead of certain tax-free benefits. If an employee chooses to receive a tax-free benefit under the plan, the fact that the employee could have received cash or a taxable benefit instead will not make the tax-free benefit taxable. The plan must be set up and operated on a nondiscriminatory basis; complicated testing rules apply.

Benefits allowed to be offered under a cafeteria plan:

  • Health and accident insurance

  • Adoption assistance

  • Dependent care assistance

  • Group-term life insurance

  • Health savings accounts

Benefits not allowed to be offered under a cafeteria plan:

  • Educational assistance

  • Meals and lodging

  • Moving expense reimbursements

  • Transportation (commuting) benefits

Simple Cafeteria Plans

Small employers can offer cafeteria plans without any complicated testing rules to ensure that the plans are nondiscriminatory. A small employer is one with 100 or fewer employees. However, once a plan is established, it can continue as a simple cafeteria plan until there are 200 employees.

What distinguishes the simple cafeteria plan from a regular cafeteria plan is mandatory employer contributions. These must be made regardless of whether employees make salary reduction contributions to the plan.

There are 2 contribution formulas that an employer can choose to use:

  1. A uniform percentage (not less than 2%) of the employee's compensation, or

  2. An amount not less than 6% of the employee's compensation or twice the employee's salary reduction contribution.

The plan must cover all employees (other than certain S corporation shareholder-employees). The plan cannot include sole proprietors, partners, members of LLCs (in most cases), or more-than-2% S corporation shareholder-employees. The plan can exclude those under age 21, those with less than one year of service, those covered by a collective bargaining agreement, and nonresident aliens working outside the United States whose income did not come from U.S. sources.

Small business owners need to decide whether the benefits of offering a cafeteria plan for employees make sense when the owners cannot participate.

Employment Tax Credits

Tax credits are even better than tax deductions. A tax deduction is worth only as much as the tax bracket you are in. For example, if you are in the top federal income tax bracket for individuals, 39.6% in 2016, a $100 deduction saves $39.60 in taxes. Tax credits reduce your taxes dollar-for-dollar. A $100 tax credit saves $100 in taxes.

Employer's Employment-Related Tax Credits

There are a number of tax credits related to the employment of workers. These tax credits reduce your deduction for compensation dollar-for-dollar. For example, if your deduction for compensation is $40,000 and you are entitled to claim a $2,000 employment tax credit, you may deduct only $38,000.

Employment-related tax credits reduce your deduction for wages paid to your employees.

WORK OPPORTUNITY CREDIT

To encourage employers to hire certain individuals from specially targeted groups, there is a tax credit called the work opportunity credit. A top credit of up to $9,600 applies to certain veterans, but smaller credits are allowed for hiring other individuals.

The credit applies for hiring an employee from one of the following targeted groups:

  1. Member of a family receiving Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF)

  2. Qualified veteran (there are 5 subcategories)

  3. Qualified ex-felon

  4. Designated community resident

  5. Vocational rehabilitation referral

  6. Summer youth employee

  7. Recipient of SNAP benefits (food stamps)

  8. SSI recipient

  9. Long-term family assistance recipient

  10. Long-term unemployed (someone who has been unemployed for at least 27 consecutive weeks and received government unemployment benefits)

The amount of the credit varies with the targeted group category and, in some cases, the term of employment. The basic credit amount is 40% of first year wages up to $6,000, for a top credit of $2,400. This basic amount applies for those who work at least 400 hours. For those who are retained on the job for at least 120 hours but not more than 400 hours, the credit percentage drops to 25%, for a top credit of $1,500. However, the credit for summer youth is limited to 40% of wages up to $3,000, for a top credit of $1,200. And the credit for veterans with service-connected disability who are employed for at least 6 months is 40% of wages up to $24,000, for a top credit of $9,600.

There is no limit on the number of employees who can be hired to generate the work opportunity credit. What's more, some states have their own work opportunity programs, so check with your state revenue department.

If you employ an eligible worker, be sure to obtain the necessary certification from your state employment security agency. This is done by having the employee sign IRS Form 8850, Pre-Screening Notice and Certification Request for the Work Opportunity Credit, on the first day of work and submitting it to your state workforce agency within 28 days of the new employee's starting work, along with the Department of Labor's Employment and Training Administration (ETA) Form 9061, Individual Characteristics Form or Form 9062, Conditional Certification. Without having submitted this form, you cannot claim the credit, but if you make a timely submission, you claim the credit even if the state agency fails to respond to you. It is highly advisable to get a new employee to sign the form and timely submit it to the state workforce agency if the agency is willing to accept it. If the work opportunity tax credit is not extended, all that is lost is your effort in the submission (i.e., no additional cost to you); if the credit is extended, then you have nailed it down and need take no further action.

Employer Credit for FICA on Tips

Owners of restaurants and beverage establishments can claim a credit for the employer portion of FICA paid on tips related to the furnishing of food and beverages on or off the premises. This is 7.65% of tips in excess of those treated as wages for purposes of satisfying the minimum wage provisions of the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA).

Empowerment Zone Employment Credit

The Departments of Housing and Urban Development and Agriculture initially named 6 cities and 3 rural economically distressed areas across the country as empowerment zones (Round I zones) and in 1998 named 22 more (Round II). In addition, the District of Columbia is an enterprise zone—another type of economically distressed area—and employers in the zone are eligible for the empowerment zone employment credit. Eight additional employment zones have been designated (Round III). If you do business in one of these economically depressed zones and hire part-time or full-time employees who perform substantially all of their employment services within the zone, you may claim a credit based on their wages. The credit is 20% of the first $15,000 of qualified wages. The top credit is $3,000 per employee per year. There is no limit on the number of employees for which you may claim the credit. Wages for purposes of calculating the credit include not only salary and wages but also training and educational benefits. To determine whether a particular area has received designation, go to http://egis.hud.gov/ezrclocator/.

Indian Employment Credit

You can claim a credit if you employ part-time or full-time workers who receive more than 50% of their wages from services performed on an Indian reservation. The employee must be an enrolled member of an Indian tribe or a spouse of an enrolled member. The employee must also live on or near the reservation on which the services are performed. The credit is 20% of the first $20,000 of excess wages and the cost of health insurance. Excess wages and health insurance costs are such costs over amounts paid or incurred during 1993. However, wages paid to any employee earning more than $30,000 are not taken into account; such employee is not a qualified employee.

Employer Wage Credit for Activated Reservists

If you continue some or all of the wages of employees called to active duty (called a differential wage payment), you can take a tax credit of 20% of the differential that does not exceed $20,000 (a top credit of $4,000).

This credit applies only to small employers (on average fewer than 50 employees) that have a written plan to provide the wage differential. No deduction for compensation can be claimed if the compensation is a differential wage payment used to determine this credit.

General Business Credit

Some employment tax credits are part of the general business credit. As such, they not only reduce your deduction for wages but are also subject to special limitations. The general business credit is the sum of employment tax credits and certain other business-related credits. The general business credit cannot exceed your net tax liability (tax liability reduced by certain personal and other credits), reduced by the greater of:

  • Tentative minimum tax (the alternative minimum tax before the foreign tax credit), or

  • 25% of regular tax liability (without regard to personal credits) over $25,000.

The amount of the general business credit in excess of this limit can be carried back for one year. Any additional excess amount can then be carried forward for up to 20 years. You cannot elect to forgo the carryback. (For credits arising in tax years before 1998, the carryback period was 3 years, and the carryforward period was 15 years. For credits arising in 2010 of small businesses with average annual gross receipts not exceeding $50 million, there was a 5-year carryback but the same 20-year carryforward.)

Employee's Employment-Related Tax Credits

An employee may be entitled to claim certain credits by virtue of working. These include the earned income credit and the dependent care credit. They are personal tax credits, not business credits. They are in addition to any child tax credit to which a person may be entitled ($1,000 for each child under age 17 if income is below a threshold amount).

Earned Income Credit

If you employ an individual whose income is below threshold amounts, the employee may be eligible to claim an earned income credit. This is a special type of credit because it can exceed tax liability. It is called a refundable credit, since it can be paid to a worker even though it more than offsets tax liability.

Note: Self-employed individuals who had a bad year in business may be eligible for the earned income credit. Find more details about this personal refundable tax credit in IRS Publication 596, Earned Income Credit (EIC).

Dependent Care Credit

Whether you are an employee or a business owner, if you hire someone to look after your children under age 13 or a disabled spouse or child of any age so that you can go to work, you may claim a tax credit. This is a personal tax credit, not a business tax credit. You claim the credit on your individual tax return.

The credit is a sliding percentage based on your adjusted gross income (AGI). The top percentage is 35%; it scales back to 20% for AGI over $43,000. This is the AGI on a joint return if you are married and do not live apart from your spouse for the entire year.

The percentage is applied to certain employment-related expenses up to $3,000 per year for one dependent, or $6,000 per year if you have 2 or more qualifying dependents. Employment-related expenses include household expenses to care for your dependent—housekeeper, babysitter, or nanny—and out-of-the-house expenses for the care of dependents, such as day-care centers, preschools, and day camps. Not treated as qualifying expenses are the costs of food; travel to and from day care, preschool, or day camp; education; and clothing. Also, the cost of sleep-away camp does not qualify as an eligible expense.

If you are eligible for a credit, be sure to get the tax identification number of anyone who works for you and the day-care center or other organization to which you pay qualified expenses. The tax identification number of an individual is his or her Social Security number. You must include this information if you want to claim the credit.

If you hire someone to work in your home, be sure to pay the nanny tax. This is the employment taxes (Social Security, Medicare, and FUTA taxes) on compensation you pay to your housekeeper, babysitter, or other in-home worker. You must pay Social Security and Medicare taxes if annual payments to a household worker in 2016 exceed $2,000. If you paid cash wages of $1,000 or more in any calendar quarter to a household employee during the current tax year or the previous year, you also must pay federal unemployment tax (FUTA) on the first $7,000 of wages. You do not pay these taxes separately but instead can report them on Schedule H and include them on your Form 1040. You should increase your withholding or estimated tax to cover your liability for them to avoid estimated tax penalties. You cannot deduct employment taxes on household workers as a business expense. However, the tax itself is treated as a qualifying expense for the dependent care credit.

Self-Employed (Including Independent Contractors and Statutory Employees)

Compensation paid to employees and employee benefits paid or provided to/for them are deductible on the appropriate lines of Schedule C. The deduction for wages must be reduced by any employment credits paid. Self-employed farmers deduct compensation costs on Schedule F. If you maintain a cafeteria plan for employees, you must file an information return, Form 5500, annually. If you personally incur dependent care costs for which a credit can be claimed, you must file Form 2441, Child and Dependent Care Expenses. The credit is then entered on Form 1040.

Partnerships and LLCs

Compensation paid to employees and employee benefits paid or provided to them are a trade or business expense taken into account in determining the profit or loss of the partnership or LLC on Form 1065, U.S. Return of Partnership Income. Report these items on the specific lines provided on Form 1065. Be sure to offset them by employment tax credits. Salaries and wages paid to employees and employee benefits are not separately stated items passed through to partners and members. Partners and members in LLCs report their net income or loss from the business on Schedule E of Form 1040; they do not deduct compensation and employee benefit costs on their individual tax returns.

Guaranteed payments to partners are also taken into account in determining trade or business profit or loss. There is a specific line on Form 1065 for reporting guaranteed payments to partners. They are also reported on Schedule K-1 as a separately stated item passed through to partners and LLC members as net earnings from self-employment. This will allow the partners and LLC members to calculate their self-employment tax on the guaranteed payments. If the partnership or LLC maintains a cafeteria plan for employees, the business must file an information return, Form 5500, annually. Partners and LLC members who personally incur dependent care costs for which a credit can be claimed must file Form 2441 with their Form 1040.

S Corporations

Compensation paid to employees and employee benefits paid or provided to them are trade or business expenses that are taken into account in determining the profit or loss of the S corporation on Form 1120S, U.S. Income Tax Return for an S Corporation. They are not separately stated items passed through to shareholders. This applies as well to compensation paid to owners employed by the corporation. Note that compensation to officers is reported on a separate line on the return from salary and wages paid to nonofficers. Be sure to reduce salary and wages by employment tax credits.

Shareholders report their net income or loss from the business on Schedule E of Form 1040; they do not deduct compensation and employee benefit costs on their individual tax returns. If the corporation maintains a cafeteria plan for employees, it must file an information return, Form 5500, annually. Shareholders who personally incur dependent care costs for which a credit can be claimed must file Form 2441 with their Form 1040.

C Corporations

Compensation and employee benefits paid to employees are trade or business expenses taken into account in determining the profit or loss of the C corporation on Form 1120, U.S. Corporation Income Tax Return. Compensation paid to officers is segregated from salaries and wages paid to employees. Be sure to reduce salary and wages by employment tax credits. Total compensation exceeding $500,000 paid to officers of the corporation is explained in greater detail on Form 1025-E, which accompanies Form 1120. Remember that the corporation then pays tax on its net profit or loss. Shareholders do not report any income (or loss) from the corporation. If the corporation maintains a cafeteria plan for employees, it must file an information return, Form 5500, annually.

Employment Tax Credits for All Businesses

Employment taxes are figured on separate forms, with the results in most cases entered on Form 3800, General Business Credit. Form 3800 need not be completed if you are claiming only 1 business credit, you have no carryback or carryover, and the credit is not from a passive activity.

The separate forms for employment taxes are the following:

  • Employer wage credit for activated reservists: Form 8932

  • Empowerment zone credit: Form 8844

  • Indian employment credit: Form 8845

  • Social Security tax credit on certain tips: Form 8846

  • Work opportunity credit: Form 5884 (and Form 8850 for certification from the state workforce agency)

..................Content has been hidden....................

You can't read the all page of ebook, please click here login for view all page.
Reset