Research and Documents
Once you have decided to get a divorce and you have taken some initial actions to protect yourself, you will want to begin the process of gathering facts and documents. You could hire a private investigator to find information for you or you could wait until you have filed for divorce to ask for information under the court’s rules for discovery. Informal and early discovery will save time and money in the long run.
Do the Research Before You Leave
Some records will be easier to find while you and your spouse are still living together. So start looking for the records you will need for your case now. Documents might be found in desk drawers, safe deposit boxes, file cabinets, briefcases, automobiles, and other places. You can have a meeting with your accountant, financial planner, and banker to go over the family finances. The following is a checklist of the type of information you should do research on before you go to court.
Assets (Before and After Marriage)
Assets are things you own, like bank accounts and furniture, for example. Here is a list of the records and documents you should try to obtain to identify and value your assets:
Note that assets can be considered marital property that the divorce court can distribute between spouses. Or they can be considered separate nonmarital property, which the divorce court cannot divide. Property you brought into the marriage, for example, is your separate property as long as you haven’t made it into, or mixed it up with, marital property. Property acquired during the marriage, with a few exceptions, is marital property. Some property can be part marital and part nonmarital. For example, a pension plan started before the marriage and contributed to during the marriage will be considered part marital and part nonmarital property. In such cases, you will have to find historical statements showing the dates and amounts of your contributions if you want to be able to keep the nonmarital portion of the property.
Liabilities (Before and After Marriage)
Liabilities refer to things you owe payments on, like student loans or credit cards. You can order your credit report for free from one of the three reporting agencies, and that will give you a starting point from which to go over your debts. Here are other documents you want to find to identify and value your liabilities:
Income
Your income includes everything for which you receive payment—your paycheck, interest, stock dividends, lottery winnings, and so on. Pay special attention to:
Expenses
Expenses are payments you make for goods and services. Make copies of canceled checks, bank statements, budgets, computer records, and other financial documents that relate to your expenses. Here’s a suggested list of expense categories to help you get started. If the expense varies from month to month, you will need about a year’s worth of records.
Additional Records
You may also find useful information in calendars, diaries, e-mail, automobile mileage records, photographs, videos, letters, package tracking bills, cell phones, and social-networking sites on the Internet. Don’t forget to Google your spouse’s name and conduct a search on Facebook. If you or your spouse has applied for a loan recently, copy any financial statements that were submitted with the application.
Tip People often keep information in their phones, day planners, computers, and so forth.
Organizing Your Research
You can put copies of all the documents you collect in individual file folders or tabbed, three-ring notebooks, as described in the preceding chapter. You will need to make an index that will also serve as a comprehensive list of all assets, liabilities, income, and expenses. This format is easy to update when new statements are issued, and you will find it very useful later during settlement discussions, mediation, discovery, and trial.
A Word About Fault and Private Investigators
Fault determines who was to blame for the breakup of the marriage. Traditionally, fault was the only way to get a divorce. Fault includes adultery, desertion, and cruelty. Now, many states have added or substituted no-fault grounds such as separation or irreconcilable differences. (I’ll have more to say on this subject in Chapter 4.)
Even in “no fault” states, however, fault may affect the outcome of your divorce. The judge may consider who was at fault when she is establishing alimony or dividing property.
Adultery is the only fault ground that is usually proven by circumstantial evidence. Private investigators are hired to provide that evidence. The investigator can follow your spouse and perhaps testify something like, “I saw them having dinner together and holding hands. They left the restaurant and went to a motel. I put a chalk mark on the tire of the car and when I returned the next morning the car had not been moved.”
The best way to find a private investigator is to ask your divorce attorney for a recommendation. Divorce attorneys are used to working with private investigators and will know the best ones to use. Investigators can also do asset searches for you if you believe your spouse is hiding assets and will not reveal them in the court’s discovery process. Investigators charge by the hour plus expenses, so be prepared to spend several-hundred to thousands of dollars for their services.
Researching the Law
Researching the law is not done to gain the expertise of a lawyer. Rather, it will help you to know where the law is found and to read summaries of it written for laypeople so you can understand what is going on in your case. The law can be found in the following places.
Constitution. The Constitution of the United States, as well as of each state, is the document that sets up the framework for the executive, legislative, and judicial branches. It gives you the rights that you enjoy, such as due process and pursuit of happiness.
Code. King Hammurabi of Babylon, born in 1792 BC, is known as the lawgiver. He produced the earliest written collection of laws, known as a code. The code was written in stone on tablets over eight feet tall. In our democracy, the people elect a legislature, which considers, deliberates, discusses, and passes laws each year. These are published in book form, and you can also find them on the Internet. There is a code for the United States, and each state has its own code of laws. The courts interpret the laws and can decide if they are constitutional or not.
Cases. If you go to trial and don’t like the result, you can appeal your case to a court of appeals. The appeals court consists of a panel of judges (who are different from the one who tried the case). The appeal judges do not try the case over again; they review the briefs submitted by counsel. These briefs are written arguments that one or more errors were committed by the trial judge. They may also review the transcript of the trial. They may affirm, vacate, modify, or reverse the decision of the trial court. Many of the orders of the appellate court are published in books called reporters. Lawyers may cite these cases as legal precedent in later trials and appeals.
Rules. Each state has rules for its courts. These are published in a book of court rules. The rules contain deadlines, descriptions of pleadings, how evidence is to be presented, and so forth. Some judges also publish rules for their particular courtroom. And there are unwritten rules, which are the customs and practices of various judges.
Where to Find the Law
The first place to look for information about the law is the Internet. If you don’t have access to the Web, you can try the public library, but you will have better luck doing legal research if there is a law library at the courthouse or a law school that you can get access to.
Tip A couple of good Web sites on which to find out about divorce law are www.divorceinfo.com run by Lee Borden and the “Divorce Support” page on www.about.com run by Cathy Meyer.
Visit the Courtroom
Nothing compares to actually watching a trial in progress. Courthouses and divorce cases are open to the public. You can gain a lot of knowledge and become more comfortable with the courtroom if you watch a few trials.
Summary
You’ve given your divorce some thought. You’ve done some research on the divorce laws in your state. You’ve begun to gather and organize the information and documents you will need. You’re probably asking yourself if you can get a divorce without a lawyer. We’ll discuss that topic in the next chapter.